Town of Canton Canton
Town of Canton

Download

Word, as adoptedXML, as adopted

Zoning audit

Town of Canton

7 things worth a decision in the Zoning By-Law: places where it does not agree with something else in it, with the contents, with the zoning map or with the Town's own record of what it has amended, and places where it would be easier to administer written another way. Each names the evidence, and says whose decision it is.

None of them are corrected in the published text. The bylaw on this site reads exactly as Canton prints it, and changing any of this is an amendment rather than a correction.

Against the text current through August 4, 2025

Needs a drafting decision 1

The bylaw contradicts itself or is incomplete here. Only Canton can settle these, and only by amendment — correcting them here would state as law something Canton has never adopted.

9 cited section number(s) do not exist in the text (11 citations)

[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The bylaw cites sections by number that the converted text does not contain. Some are references to other bylaws or to a superseded numbering; some will be sections the PDF reader failed to recognise. Either way a reader who follows the citation finds nothing.

  • § 4.0 cited 3 time(s); e.g. § 4.3 4.3.4: “…a building, notwithstanding the height limits otherwise set forth in Section 4.0, in accordance with the following provisions”
  • § 9.0 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § 2.2: “…, the following overlay and special districts are also established in Section 9.0”
  • § 8.0 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § 4.1 4.1.3: “…elling, or so used, shall be located on any lot except as provided by Section 8.0 Special Residential Regulations.”
  • § 4.4 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § 4.3 2.: “…ty-two feet (52’) (except for non-habitable structures as provided in Section 4.4) or provide for more than four stories, and”

For each number, decide whether it is a stale citation to amend or a section the conversion missed to re-read.

read from the Town's materials

The amendment record 3

Where Canton's own record of what it adopted disagrees with the text it adopted, or with itself. These are questions for the Clerk's files rather than for Town Meeting.

§ 3.2The edition drops the opening of § 3.2.6, Accessory Scientific Uses, which its contents list and its 2017 edition prints

The contents (p. i) list "3.2.6 Accessory Scientific Uses" on page 8, but the body on page 8 goes from § 3.2.5's item 4 straight to a line that begins mid-sentence, "permitted as a matter of right, accessory to activities permitted as a matter of right, which activities are necessary in connection with scientific research ...". The Town's 2017 edition (town.canton.ma.us, DocumentCenter/View/3407, "Amended through ATM 2017") prints the provision whole: "3.2.6 Accessory Scientific Uses. Uses, whether or not on the same parcel as activities permitted as a matter of right, accessory to activities permitted as a matter of right, ..."; the rest is word for word the 2026 text. No amendment of § 3.2.6 was found. This site publishes the 2026 edition as printed: § 3.2.6 has no number or heading here, and its words stand as a paragraph closing § 3.2.5's list. The use table still lists "Accessory scientific uses" (Attachment A, J).

  • 2026 edition, p. 8, after § 3.2.5 item 4: “permitted as a matter of right, accessory to activities permitted as a matter of right, which activities are necessary in connection with scientific research or scientific development or related production, may be permitted upon the issuance of a special permit provided the Zoning Board of Appeals finds that the proposed accessory use does not substantially derogate from the public good.”
  • 2017 edition, § 3.2.6: “3.2.6 Accessory Scientific Uses. Uses, whether or not on the same parcel as activities permitted as a matter of right, accessory to activities permitted as a matter of right, which activities are necessary in connection with scientific research ...”

A matter for the Town's next edition: restore the number, heading and opening words of § 3.2.6.

read from the Town's materials

§ 8.1The edition prints words in § 8.1 and in § 11.0's definition of Accessory Dwelling Unit that the Attorney General disapproved and deleted on June 4, 2025 (references to single-family dwellings, the as-of-right limit, the minimum lot size, the setback rule and parts of the parking rule)

§ 8.1, Accessory Dwelling Units, and § 11.0's definition of Accessory Dwelling Unit are Articles 8 and 6 of the Special Town Meeting of November 18, 2024. The Attorney General's decision of June 4, 2025 (Case # 11654) partly approves them: “We partially approve Articles 6 and 8 because the approved text does not conflict with state law. However, we disapprove the following provisions because they conflict with G.L. c. 40A, § 3 and the Regulations ...: references to “single-family” dwelling in Sections 8.14; 8.16 (A) and (C) and 11.0; Section 8.1.2 that limits an as-of-right ADU only where single-family homes are allowed as-of-right; Section 8.1.2 (B) that imposes a minimum lot size requirement for construction of an ADU; a portion of Section 8.1.2 (D) that imposes a setback requirement that is the same setback requirement as the primary residence; and a portion of Section 8.1.6’s parking requirements.” Each passage is quoted in the decision with the deleted words set in bold and underline: “single-family” (twice) in the definition; “as-of-right” in the phrase “in which single-family homes are allowed as-of-right”; the whole of § 8.1.2 B; “the same” and “as the primary residence,” in § 8.1.2 D; “single-family” in § 8.1.4; “a minimum of” and “for the single-family residence” in § 8.1.6 A; “over and above that of the underlying zoning district” in § 8.1.6 B; and “single-family” in § 8.1.6 C. The 2026 edition prints every one of these words, as adopted. This site publishes § 8.1 and the definition as the Town prints them, these words included. The Annual Town Meeting of May 11, 2026 has since rewritten § 8.1 and the definition (the next finding).

  • § 8.1.2, as printed: “One Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) shall be allowed as-of-right in all zoning districts in which single-family homes ae allowed as-of-right, subject to the following restrictions:” and “B. The Lot contains a minimum of 5,000 square feet of area;”; “D. The ADU is subject to the same dimensional setbacks as the primary residence, as provided in Section 4.0 of this Zoning By-Law;”
  • § 8.1.4, as printed: “The ADU shall be designed so that the appearance of the structure remains that of a single-family dwelling, subject further to the following requirements:”
  • § 8.1.6, as printed: “A. There shall be a minimum of one (1) off-street parking space per ADU in addition to the parking spaces that are required by the underlying zoning district for the single-family residence;” “B. No additional parking spaces over and above that of the underlying zoning district shall be required if the ADU is located within 0.5 miles from a commuter rail station, subway station, ferry terminal, or bus station.” “C. A single driveway shall serve both the single-family residential structure and the ADU, provided that a detached ADU may have a separate parking area.”
  • § 11.0, as printed: “Accessory Dwelling Unit: A secondary dwelling unit, but not a mobile home, located either within or on the same lot as a detached single-family dwelling. The accessory dwelling unit shall be subordinate in size to the principal dwelling unit and separated from it in a manner that maintains the appearance of the structure as a single-family house.”
  • Attorney General, June 4, 2025, Case # 11654, Special Town Meeting of November 18, 2024, Articles 6 and 8: “We disapprove and delete the text “as-of-right” because it conflicts with G.L. c. 40A, § 3 and the Regulations”; “Because the Regulations, 760 CMR 71.03 (3)(b)(2), prohibit a Town from requiring a minimum lot size for a Protected Use ADU, Section 8.1.2 (B) conflicts with the Regulations and we therefore disapprove the text shown above in bold and underline.”

Read § 8.1 and the definition without the disapproved words, and as amended in May 2026 (next finding), until the Town publishes a compilation that carries both.

read from the Town's materials

The Annual Town Meeting of May 11, 2026 amended § 8.1, § 11.0 and the Zoning Map after this edition was compiled (approved September 22, 2026, Case

This edition, the Town's "Town of Canton Zoning By-Laws 2026", is dated on its cover "2026, Amended through STM 2025" and was compiled on April 7, 2026 (the PDF's own date). The last meeting it carries is the Special Town Meeting of August 4, 2025 (Article 2, § 9.1, approved December 12, 2025, Case # 12008); its § 9.1.3 names the Flood Insurance Rate Map of July 8, 2025 that article adopted. The Annual Town Meeting of May 11, 2026 adopted five zoning articles, all approved by the Attorney General on September 22, 2026 (Case # 12417), none of them in this edition: (1) Article 43 amends § 8.1, Accessory Dwelling Units: § 8.1.2 allows one ADU in every district where single-family homes are allowed "as-of-right or by Special Permit", strikes the rule that the ADU is subject to the primary residence's setbacks, and reletters the restrictions; a new § 8.1.3, Additional Accessory Dwelling Units, lets the Board of Appeals grant a special permit for ADUs beyond the first; § 8.1.4's appearance test becomes "the principal structure"; § 8.1.6's parking becomes one space per ADU in addition to the spaces required "for the Principal Use", none near transit, and one driveway for the "primary use" and the ADU. (2) Article 44 amends § 11.0's definition of Accessory Dwelling Unit to a unit "on the same lot as a principal dwelling", the appearance to be "of the structure" without "as a single family house". Both were moved with the clerical correction of "principle" to "principal". (3) Articles 45, 46 and 47 amend the Zoning Map by removing the Canton Center Economic Opportunity Districts A, B and C (the district's text, § 9.8, was deleted by Article 34 of the Annual Town Meeting of May 12, 2025, approved September 10, 2025, Case # 11916, and the edition prints § 9.8 as Not Used). The Attorney General's lookup lists no later Canton decision. The text published here does not include Articles 43 and 44, and the map here does not show the CCEOD either way (the September layer has no CCEOD polygons).

  • Attorney General, September 22, 2026, Case # 12417, Annual Town Meeting of May 11, 2026, Warrant Articles # 43, 44, 45, 46, and 47 (Zoning): “We approve Articles 24 through 33 and 43 through 47, and the map amendments adopted under 45, 46, and 47 from the Canton May 11, 2026 Annual Town Meeting.”
  • Town Clerk's legal notice with the decision (town.canton.ma.us/DocumentCenter/View/13842): “Article 43 - AMEND ZONING BY-LAW SECTION 8.1 ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS; Article 44 - AMEND ZONING BY-LAW SECTION 11 DEFINITIONS; Article 45 - AMEND ZONING MAP - REMOVING CCEOD A; Article 46 - AMEND ZONING MAP - REMOVING CCEOD B; Article 47 - amend zoning map - removing cceod c”; each article “VOTED: ... adopted as printed. ADOPTED UNANIMOUS VOICE VOTE”.
  • Edition, cover: “TOWN OF CANTON 2026 Amended through STM 2025”; § 9.1.3: “... the Norfolk County Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM) dated July 8, 2025 ...”.
  • Attorney General, Municipal Law Unit decision lookup (massago.hylandcloud.com/231publicaccess/MLU.html), City/Town CANTON, checked 2026-11-04: 31 decisions, the latest of September 22, 2026 (Case # 12417); the one before it of December 12, 2025 (Case # 12008, Special Town Meeting of August 4, 2025).

A matter for the Town Clerk's record and the Town's next edition. Once the Town publishes an edition carrying Articles 43 and 44, it can be converted in place of this one.

read from the Town's materials

Between the bylaw and the map 2

The bylaw and the zoning map are one instrument, and these are the places where they do not agree.

4 district code(s) the text establishes are not on the map layer

[Automated statute and consistency scan, low confidence.] The bylaw names these districts with a code in parentheses and the map layer we hold has no polygon carrying that code. Overlay districts commonly sit on a separate layer; a base district missing from the map is a gap.

  • Text names (CJOD); map has no CJOD
  • Text names (GPOD); map has no GPOD
  • Text names (HOD); map has no HOD
  • Text names (SPOD); map has no SPOD

Check whether each is an overlay on another layer or a base district the map should carry.

read from the Town's materials

9 map district code(s) never appear in the bylaw text

[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The zoning map layer carries these district codes, and the converted bylaw text never writes them. Either the map uses abbreviations the bylaw does not (the bylaw may name the district in words), the layer is not the map of record, or the text is stale.

  • Map code SRAA: no match in text
  • Map code SRA: no match in text
  • Map code SRB: no match in text
  • Map code SRC: no match in text

Match each code to the district the bylaw establishes by name, in districts.yaml, or replace the layer.

read from the Town's materials

Against the enabling statute 1

Where the ordinance appears to require, permit or prohibit something the state act it is adopted under does not allow it to. These are readings of two published texts side by side, not legal advice, and each names the provision on both sides so counsel can check it rather than take our word.

§ 11.0An accessory dwelling provision appears to require a special permit

[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] MGL c. 40A, § 3 forbids a bylaw to "require a special permit or other discretionary zoning approval for the use of land or structures for a single accessory dwelling unit" in a single-family residential district. This provision mentions a special permit in the same breath as the accessory dwelling.

  • § 11.0: “Accessory Apartment: A pre-existing non-conforming dwelling unit created in a single-family dwelling by special permit granted by the zoning board of appeals and recorded at the Norfolk County registry of deeds prior to the adop…”
  • MGL c. 40A, § 3: "shall not ... require a special permit or other discretionary zoning approval for the use of land or structures for a single accessory dwelling unit"

Read the provision: a special permit for a second ADU, or for an ADU larger than the statute protects, is allowed; one for the first protected ADU is not.

read from the Town's materials

Published by the Town of Canton. The official code of record is maintained by the Town Clerk.

Text current through August 4, 2025