Zoning audit
Town of Chebeague Island
8 things worth a decision in
the Zoning Ordinance: places where it does not agree with something else in it, with
the contents, with the zoning map or with the Town's own record of what it has amended, and places where it would be easier to administer written another
way. Each names the evidence, and says whose decision it is.
None of them are corrected in the published text. The
ordinance on this site reads exactly as Chebeague Island prints it, and
changing any of this is an amendment rather than a correction.
Against the text current through June 7, 2025
Needs a drafting decision 3
The ordinance contradicts itself or is incomplete here. Only Chebeague Island can settle these, and only by amendment — correcting them here would state as law something Chebeague Island has never adopted.
§ 204.1Footnote 1 and the contents still describe Section 407 as it stood before June 8, 2024
The Town Meeting of June 8, 2024 repealed Section 407 ("Conversions": 407.1 Accessory Apartments, 407.2 Manor Houses, 407.3 Condominium) and replaced it with "Accessory Dwelling Units (ADU’s) and Duplexes" (407.1 Accessory Dwelling Units, 407.2 Duplexes, 407.3 Lot Rules for ADUs and Duplexes), the Planning Board's answer to LD 2003. Footnote 1 to § 204.1.A.1 still says accessory apartments and "manor houses" "are defined and regulated under Sec. 407: Conversions", and the contents (page iii) still list 407.1 to 407.3 by their old titles; the new § 407 regulates neither by those names, and § 110 defines neither. (A copy of the edition saved on June 20, 2024, also posted, printed the old 407.2 and 407.3 after the new 407.3; the December 27, 2024 edition published here does not.) Footnotes, § 103.1 says, are not part of the ordinance. Published as printed.
- § 204.1, footnote 1: "Accessory apartments and “manor houses” are also allowed in the IR district. They are defined and regulated under Sec. 407: Conversions."
- Planning Board warrant explanation, 2024: "This version replaces the original section called “Conversions” and reflects the mandate under State law LD2003"
A clean-up amendment of the footnote, and a new contents page (which the Planning Board may change without a vote, § 103.1).
read from the Town's materials
§ 205.4Section 205.4 cites a § 204.3 the ordinance does not have
§ 205.4 lets a lot of at least 20,000 square feet on a subdivision plan recorded by July 31, 1975 be built upon "subject to the conditions in sec 204.1.C, D, and E, or sec. 204.3.C, D, and E". Section 204 has two provisions, 204.1 (IR) and 204.2 (IB); 204.2.C, D and E are the IB district's lot standards and setbacks, which is likely what is meant. The second citation is published as printed and left unlinked.
- § 205.4: "... may be built upon subject to the conditions in sec 204.1.C, D, and E, or sec. 204.3.C, D, and E."
Decide whether "204.3" should read "204.2".
read from the Town's materials
4 cited section number(s) do not exist in the text (5 citations)
[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The bylaw cites sections by number that the converted text does not contain. Some are references to other bylaws or to a superseded numbering; some will be sections the PDF reader failed to recognise. Either way a reader who follows the citation finds nothing.
- § 7.15 cited 2 time(s); e.g. § 409 C.: “…are Centers and Nursery Schools shall be subject to the provisions of Sec. 7.15 – Sewage Disposal – of the Town of Chebeague Island Subdivision Ordin…”
- § 4.4 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § 405: “…e Ordinance listed below can be met. Such developments are subject to Section 4.4 of the Subdivision Ordinance. All such residential developments shall…”
- § 7.5 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § 405: “…not required to include land set aside as open space, as provided in Section 7.5 of the Subdivision Ordinance.”
- § 7.8 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § 422: “…Island Subdivision Ordinance under Sections 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 (except for Sec. 7.8 and 7.9), 8, 9, 10, and Appendix D; provided, however, such subdivisi…”
For each number, decide whether it is a stale citation to amend or a section the conversion missed to re-read.
read from the Town's materials
The amendment record 1
Where Chebeague Island's own record of what it adopted disagrees with the text it adopted, or with itself. These are questions for the Clerk's files rather than for Town Meeting.
§ 110The Planning Board's 2025 proposals to amend § 110 have not gone to Town Meeting
On April 22, 2025 the Planning Board held a public hearing on, besides the parking amendment the Town Meeting adopted on June 7, 2025 (§ 419.1, published here), amendments to § 110: the note under "Upland Edge" on the Highest Astronomical Tide (striking the tidal epoch's years) and "Variance", whose shoreland sentence would read "may" for "shall". They were not on the warrant of June 7, 2025; the Board's agendas of September 8, September 18 and October 14, 2025 list them for further discussion "based on feedback from public hearings", and none of the town meetings since (January 24, April 10 and June 6, 2026) acted on them. Its agendas of January 26, February 9, March 16 and May 11, 2026 list a review of possible revisions and a hearing schedule, with no text. Nothing of these is published here.
- Planning Board public hearing notice, April 22, 2025, item 2(b): "Zoning Ordinance Section 110, Definitions, to make small clarifying modifications suggested by the Maine Department of Environment Protection"
None until the Town Meeting acts.
read from the Town's materials
Between the bylaw and the map 3
The ordinance and the zoning map are one instrument, and these are the places where they do not agree.
§ 109Section 109 dates the Official Zoning Map April 7, 2018; the certified copy says June 9, 2018
§ 109 adopts the map "officially entitled "Town of Chebeague Island Zoning Map" dated April 7, 2018 (Appendix A)". The certified copy the Town posts on its Code Enforcement page ("Official Zoning Map Adopted 2019", 2018-05-23_Zoning_Map.pdf, a scan) is titled "Official Zoning Map / Town of Chebeague Island, Maine" and certified "as adopted by the vote of the Town Meeting June 9, 2018"; the Planning Board page links a "DRAFT Zoning Map" (Zoning_Map_2018.pdf, scanned March 26, 2018). The ordinance's cover lists an amendment of April 7, 2018 and none of June 9, 2018. Neither Appendix A, B (the FIRM) nor C (the Aquifer Protection Map) is attached to the edition. The map published here is the Town's Zoning GIS layer (data of 2021), which draws the same districts as the certified copy.
- Official Zoning Map: "I certify this to be a true copy of the Official Zoning Map as adopted by the vote of the Town Meeting June 9, 2018"
Confirm which Town Meeting adopted the map in force, and attach Appendices A to C to the posted edition.
read from the Town's materials
§ 302The Aquifer Protection areas and the Resource Protection/Floodplain Overlay are on no published map
§ 302 applies Section 300 to the areas designated Aquifer Protection (AP) on "the official aquifer protection map (Appendix C) dated July 1, 2007", which the Town does not post and which is on no public GIS layer; the Official Zoning Map's note says "All inhabited islands are included in the Aquifer Protection District". § 109 names a Resource Protection/Floodplain Overlay (RP/FP) that neither the Official Zoning Map's legend nor the Town's Shoreland Zoning layer shows apart from Resource Protection. Neither is drawn on the map published here.
- Official Zoning Map, note: "All inhabited islands are included in the Aquifer Protection District."
Ask the Town for Appendix C, and whether RP/FP is mapped.
read from the Town's materials
1 district code(s) the text establishes are not on the map layer
[Automated statute and consistency scan, low confidence.] The bylaw names these districts with a code in parentheses and the map layer we hold has no polygon carrying that code. Overlay districts commonly sit on a separate layer; a base district missing from the map is a gap.
- Text names (LC); map has no LC
Check whether each is an overlay on another layer or a base district the map should carry.
read from the Town's materials
Worth taking up at the next amendment 1
Nothing here contradicts anything, and nothing here exceeds the statute. These are places where what is written makes the ordinance harder to administer, to cite or to read than it needs to be. Each is still a change only Chebeague Island can make.
List markers, a repeated paragraph and words the edition misprints
Published as printed: § 414.1 letters its conditions A., B., B., C., E., F., G. (and its closing sentence counts "the seven (7) conditions above"); several markers lack or double their point ("A The following uses", "C The following lot standards" and "B No more than" in § 204.2 and § 110, "B Submission Requirements" in § 206.7, "E Change of Use" in § 501.2, "C.." in § 427.9) or set it first (".D" in "Undue Hardship"); § 416.9 ends with the paragraph on outdoor lighting that § 417.8 prints again; § 109 "Shoreland Zoning Overly districts"; § 206.7.A.6 "Eleven (11))"; § 406.1.H "The amount of open space that shall be required shall be required shall be at least 50%"; § 417.3.B "417,3.A.2"; § 603.2.A "Upon appeal by from a decision"; § 603.3.D "30-A M.S.R. § 2691".
- § 414.1: "B. In the case of a home occupation ..." / "B. In the case of a home-based occupation ..." / "C. ..." / "E. ..."
read from the Town's materials