Town of Edgecomb Edgecomb
Town of Edgecomb

Download

Word, as adoptedXML, as adopted

Zoning audit

Town of Edgecomb

5 things worth a decision in the Land Use Ordinance: places where it does not agree with something else in it, with the contents, with the zoning map or with the Town's own record of what it has amended, and places where it would be easier to administer written another way. Each names the evidence, and says whose decision it is.

None of them are corrected in the published text. The ordinance on this site reads exactly as Edgecomb prints it, and changing any of this is an amendment rather than a correction.

Against the text current through May 18, 2024

Needs a drafting decision 2

The ordinance contradicts itself or is incomplete here. Only Edgecomb can settle these, and only by amendment — correcting them here would state as law something Edgecomb has never adopted.

§ III.4Cross-references and a footnote that do not match the ordinance's own numbering

Kept as printed (NOTES.md lists them all). The Development Criteria Table marks the Woodland District's front setback with footnote 9, and the table prints footnotes 1 to 8 only. § II.1 (1.1.2) and § VI.1 (1.7.4) send map amendments to "Article I, Section 6", which is Conflicts; amendments are Article I, Section 7. § V.3's submission list cites "Section 4.15" for the stormwater plan, "Section 4.6" for erosion control, "Section 4.13" for phosphorus control and "Section 4.8" for the hydrogeologic assessment, where § V.4 numbers them 4.8, 4.5, 4.7 and 4.6. § VI.2 says terms are "defined in Section 2.8", where its definitions are 2.13. § X.2 regulates shoreland tree cutting "pursuant to Article III Section 1.10.16", which is § VI.1's 1.13.15; § VI.4's 4.3.2.9 cites "Section 5.4 of this Ordinance" for the mobile home safety standards, which are its 4.4.5.13.

  • § III.4, Woodland row: “50 ft.⁹”
  • § II.1 (1.1.2): “Amendments to the official Zoning Districts Map shall be in accordance with Article I, Section 6 of this ordinance.”

For the Town: supply footnote 9 and correct the cross-references at the next amendment.

read from the Town's materials

2 cited section number(s) do not exist in the text (2 citations)

[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The bylaw cites sections by number that the converted text does not contain. Some are references to other bylaws or to a superseded numbering; some will be sections the PDF reader failed to recognise. Either way a reader who follows the citation finds nothing.

  • § 10.1.1 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § VI.1 (iii): “…upland edge of a wetland must meet the footprint and height limits in Section 10.1.1(b)(i) and Section 1.10.1.1 (c)(i), above.”
  • § 1.10.16 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § X.2: “…utting or removal of trees shall be regulated pursuant to Article III Section 1.10.16, Clearing or Removal of Vegetation for Activities Other Than Timber H…”

For each number, decide whether it is a stale citation to amend or a section the conversion missed to re-read.

read from the Town's materials

The amendment record 1

Where Edgecomb's own record of what it adopted disagrees with the text it adopted, or with itself. These are questions for the Clerk's files rather than for Town Meeting.

§ I.1The edition is current as far as the Town's posted record reaches; two gaps

The posted Land Use Ordinance is "as amended through May 18, 2024", the session of the Annual Town Meeting at which Article 40 enacted the "May 17, 2024 Amendments to the Land Use Ordinance" (the Town's 2023-2024 annual report). Since then: the special town meetings of July 1 and October 29, 2024 (the Fire and Rescue Department Ordinance; a TIF appropriation), the secret-ballot Annual Town Meeting of May 17, 2025 (its proceedings in the 2024-2025 annual report), and the referendum of November 3, 2026 (the Town's voter guide and results post: liquor, the Fire and Rescue Department Ordinance, a capital reserve) adopted no amendment to it; the Planning Board's minutes and agendas of 2025 and 2026 record no public hearing on one, and the Ordinance Review Committee's minutes of 2025 and 2026 record research and the Waterfront Ordinance, which it held back from the 2026 warrant. Two gaps: the full results of the May 16, 2026 Annual Town Meeting are not readable (the results PDF the Town's post attaches answers 410 Gone; the post itself lists the offices and the school budget, school paving and water district articles), and the 2023-2024 annual report prints Article 40's text without the underline and strike-through marks its note describes, so the posted ordinance could not be checked against it word for word (it differs from the report's text in 1.13.1.5, in § VI.5's 5.1.3, "must not" for "may not", and in the report's definition of "Accessory Apartment", which the posted Article X does not carry).

  • Page 4: “Enacted May 21, 2005. Amended ... substantially amended May 21, 2016, May 19, 2018 and May 18, 2024.”
  • Annual report 2023-2024, Article 40: “Moved, seconded and voted to enact the “May 17, 2024 Amendments to the Land Use Ordinance” ... (Note: Changes in text are indicated by underscore for additions and strike through for deletion)”

Ask the Town Clerk for the May 16, 2026 results and for the text of the 2024 amendments as adopted.

read from the Town's materials

Between the bylaw and the map 2

The ordinance and the zoning map are one instrument, and these are the places where they do not agree.

§ II.1The zoning map is read from the Town's Official Zoning Map, a PDF that is not georeferenced

No public, downloadable GIS layer of Edgecomb's zoning was found. The nine districts, and the four shoreland districts as overlays, are read from the Town's own Official Zoning Map ("Official Zoning Map, Town of Edgecomb, Maine, April 11, 2013", attested by the Town Clerk March 29, 2018, its note 5 "revised January 2, 2018 to shade Shoreland Zones"; the file the Town posts, "13007 ZONING MAP attested 3-29-2018 corrected 7-30-2026.pdf", was printed July 30, 2026), as the vector hatches it shades each district with, placed on the earth by fitting the map's parcel lines to the state's 2009 parcels (median residual 0.5 m, 90th percentile 1.3 m; map_layers.py). The map's own notes call its depiction of the districts "merely illustrative of their general location", say it is compiled from the April 2000 tax maps, and say its Resource Protection areas are only possible steep slopes (§ VI.1, 1.11.1.3), the other Resource Protection areas of 1.11.1.1, 1.11.1.2, 1.11.1.4 and 1.11.1.5 not being shown; the Resource Protection District drawn here is therefore incomplete. § II.2 describes each base district in words, by tax map lots and distances from road centerlines, and § VI.1 describes the shoreland districts by distance from water and wetlands; where the words and the map differ, which governs is not settled by the ordinance's text. The file's name says the map was "corrected" on July 30, 2026; no record of what was corrected, or of a Town Meeting vote amending the map since 2018, was found (the Select Board's minutes of December 9, 2025 record the Planning Board's request to buy an updated map from the surveyor).

  • § II.1 (1.1): “the Town of Edgecomb is hereby divided into the following zoning districts, which shall be shown on an official map to be created by the Planning Board, certified by the Town Clerk, and made a part of this ordinance.”
  • § VI.1 (1.11): “The Districts are as shown on the Official Shoreland Zoning Map or described herein by dimension or reference to a physical feature.”
  • Official Zoning Map, note 3: “Resource Protection District areas shown hereon are based on possible areas of sustained steep slopes pursuant to Article III, Section 1.8.1.3 of the ordinance. Additional areas which meet this criteria may exist.”

Ask the Town for the map's source drawing or a GIS layer of it, and for what the July 30, 2026 correction changed.

read from the Town's materials

5 map district code(s) never appear in the bylaw text

[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The zoning map layer carries these district codes, and the converted bylaw text never writes them. Either the map uses abbreviations the bylaw does not (the bylaw may name the district in words), the layer is not the map of record, or the text is stale.

  • Map code ETD: no match in text
  • Map code CGD: no match in text
  • Map code R27-I: no match in text
  • Map code R27-II: no match in text

Match each code to the district the bylaw establishes by name, in districts.yaml, or replace the layer.

read from the Town's materials

The official code of record is maintained by the Town Clerk.

Text current through May 18, 2024