Town of Manchester-by-the-Sea Manchester-by-the-Sea
Town of Manchester-by-the-Sea

Download

Word, as adoptedXML, as adopted

Zoning audit

Town of Manchester-by-the-Sea

5 things worth a decision in the Zoning By-Law: places where it does not agree with something else in it, with the contents, with the zoning map or with the Town's own record of what it has amended, and places where it would be easier to administer written another way. Each names the evidence, and says whose decision it is.

None of them are corrected in the published text. The bylaw on this site reads exactly as Manchester-by-the-Sea prints it, and changing any of this is an amendment rather than a correction.

Against the text current through April 27, 2026

Needs a drafting decision 1

The bylaw contradicts itself or is incomplete here. Only Manchester-by-the-Sea can settle these, and only by amendment — correcting them here would state as law something Manchester-by-the-Sea has never adopted.

32 cited section number(s) do not exist in the text (48 citations)

[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The bylaw cites sections by number that the converted text does not contain. Some are references to other bylaws or to a superseded numbering; some will be sections the PDF reader failed to recognise. Either way a reader who follows the citation finds nothing.

  • § 5.0 cited 4 time(s); e.g. § 2.0: “Lot Area: The horizontal area of a lot. For purposes of Section 5.0 the area of a lot shall not include: (1) The area within the limitati…”
  • § 9.3.5.1 cited 4 time(s); e.g. § 9.3: “…may offer, and the Planning Board may accept, any combination of the Section 9.3.5.1(a)-(d) requirements provided that in no event shall the total number…”
  • § 4.1.10 cited 4 time(s); e.g. § Appendix: “Article 21: Amended Section 4.1.10(i) requiring a Special Permit for raising and keeping livestock”
  • § 7.0 cited 3 time(s); e.g. § 12.5: “…ction shall not apply to applications for special permits pursuant to Section 7.0 to alter a nonconformity. The Zoning Board of Appeals shall establish…”

For each number, decide whether it is a stale citation to amend or a section the conversion missed to re-read.

read from the Town's materials

Between the bylaw and the map 2

The bylaw and the zoning map are one instrument, and these are the places where they do not agree.

2 map district code(s) never appear in the bylaw text

[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The zoning map layer carries these district codes, and the converted bylaw text never writes them. Either the map uses abbreviations the bylaw does not (the bylaw may name the district in words), the layer is not the map of record, or the text is stale.

  • Map code D-1: no match in text
  • Map code D-2: no match in text

Match each code to the district the bylaw establishes by name, in districts.yaml, or replace the layer.

read from the Town's materials

The zoning map lacks the Town Center and Harbor's Edge Districts of April 27, 2026; they wait for the Town's own layer

The map's districts are the September onboarding's copy of the Town's AxisGIS layer "Zoning": the eight districts A, B, C, D-1, D-2, E, G, and LCD. Section 3.1 establishes ten. The Annual Town Meeting of April 27, 2026 created the Town Center District (TC) and the Harbor's Edge District (HE) from land the layer draws in other districts, mostly the General District (Article 20, adopted by two-thirds, 149 to 7; approved with its map by the Attorney General on July 30, 2026, Case # 12233). The Town's live AxisGIS layer, last synced November 15, 2026, still has the same eight codes, and no public layer found carries TC or HE; the Town posts only a picture of them ("Downtown District Map - Final", DocumentCenter/View/9403, dated February 11, 2026), which is not traced. Until the Town's layer arrives, TC and HE are not in districts.yaml, their parcels join to the district the old layer draws there, and the Table of Allowed Uses, Section 5.4, and Section 8.5 govern land the map shows as another district. On the owner's decision of 2026-11-18, map_layers.py draws the three overlays public layers carry: the Community Housing Overlay Districts (CHOD, Section 9.4, the G.L. c. 40A, Section 3A overlay; six polygons, 39.73 acres, from MassGIS's MBTA Communities 3A District Atlas), the Flood Control District (FCD, Section 10.1; the Town's AxisGIS layer 222), and the Ground and Surface Water Resource Overlay Protection Districts (GSWROPD, Section 10.3; Zones I, II, III, and C from the Town's AxisGIS layer 223). Also not drawn: Zones A and B of the Ground and Surface Water Resource Overlay Protection Districts, which no layer found carries, and the Floodplain Overlay District of Section 10.2, which that section defines by FEMA's flood insurance rate map.

  • map/zoning.geojson (the Town's AxisGIS layer "Zoning", services8.arcgis.com/EvnSQRphNDboBLpY/arcgis/rest/services/AxisGISDataSync/FeatureServer/225, fetched 2026-09-18): ZONE A, B, C, D-1, D-2, E, G, LCD. The live layer queried 2026-11-16: 133 features with the same eight values of ZONING, last edited 2026-11-15.
  • Town Clerk's vote certification, Annual Town Meeting of April 27, 2026, Article 20 ("to create and regulate two new zoning districts as shown on the Map on file with the Town Clerk entitled 'Town Center and Harbor's Edge Districts'"), and the Attorney General's decision of July 30, 2026 (Case # 12233), "We approve Article 20, and the related map amendment".
  • map/overlays.geojson, written by map_layers.py on 2026-11-17 from ~/zoning-work/raw/manchester-ma/map/: mbta-3a-manchester.geojson (MassGIS atlas, MUNI Manchester-by-the-Sea, six features, status Compliant), flood-control-district-222.geojson (four features, areas A-1, A-2, B-1, and one unlabeled), water-resource-protection-223.geojson (Zone 1, Zone 2, Zone 3, Zone C).

The owner will ask the Town for its current zoning layer. With it, draw the Town Center and Harbor's Edge Districts in place of the old layer's polygons there, add TC and HE to districts.yaml (named as Section 3.1 names them, colored as mixed use and business), and rerun the parcel join.

read from the Town's materials

Against the enabling statute 2

Where the ordinance appears to require, permit or prohibit something the state act it is adopted under does not allow it to. These are readings of two published texts side by side, not legal advice, and each names the provision on both sides so counsel can check it rather than take our word.

§ 10.3 (c)An agricultural use appears restricted without the § 3 acreage exemption stated

[Automated statute and consistency scan, low confidence.] MGL c. 40A, § 3 provides that no bylaw shall prohibit, unreasonably regulate or require a special permit for agriculture, aquaculture, silviculture, horticulture, floriculture or viticulture on parcels of more than five acres (two acres where the use generates the stated sales).

  • § 10.3 (c): “…e application of pesticides, herbicides, fertilizers, fungicides, and rodenticides for non-residential or non-agricultural purposes shall require a special permit.”

Confirm the bylaw states the exemption somewhere; if not, the row is enforceable only below the acreage threshold.

read from the Town's materials

§ AppendixAn accessory dwelling provision appears to require a special permit

[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] MGL c. 40A, § 3 forbids a bylaw to "require a special permit or other discretionary zoning approval for the use of land or structures for a single accessory dwelling unit" in a single-family residential district. This provision mentions a special permit in the same breath as the accessory dwelling.

  • § Appendix: “…ng an alteration of a non-conforming structure that does not make the structure more non-conforming without a special permit. Article 32; permits construction of accessory dwelling units in single residence districts. Article 34; spec…”
  • MGL c. 40A, § 3: "shall not ... require a special permit or other discretionary zoning approval for the use of land or structures for a single accessory dwelling unit"

Read the provision: a special permit for a second ADU, or for an ADU larger than the statute protects, is allowed; one for the first protected ADU is not.

read from the Town's materials

The official code of record is maintained by the Town Clerk.

Text current through April 27, 2026