Zoning audit
Town of Scarborough
8 things worth a decision in
the Zoning Ordinance: places where it does not agree with something else in it, with
the contents, with the zoning map or with the Town's own record of what it has amended, and places where it would be easier to administer written another
way. Each names the evidence, and says whose decision it is.
None of them are corrected in the published text. The
ordinance on this site reads exactly as Scarborough prints it, and
changing any of this is an amendment rather than a correction.
Against the text current through October 21, 2026
Needs a drafting decision 3
The ordinance contradicts itself or is incomplete here. Only Scarborough can settle these, and only by amendment — correcting them here would state as law something Scarborough has never adopted.
§ IISection II.B's list of districts no longer matches the districts the ordinance regulates
Section II.B ("Establishment of Zones", last amended 09/05/2012) divides the Town into classes of districts, and still lists R-F, R-F-M, R-2, R-3, R-4 and R-4A, which Section XIII (07/19/2023) replaced with RF, RFM, R2, R3, R4 and R4A, and omits the Light Industrial District (Section XXI.B, adopted 03/20/2013) and the Higgins Beach character districts (Section XVI.B, adopted 12/02/2015).
- Section II.B: "Rural and Farming District R-F [05/05/10] ... Residential 4A District R-4A ..."
- Section XIII: "RURAL FARMING DISTRICT RF ... RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT R4A."
Bring Section II.B's list up to date at the next amendment.
read from the Town's materials
No provision establishes Coastal Beach Zone
Coastal Beach Zone is drawn on the zoning map and regulated elsewhere in the bylaw, and no provision establishes it or fixes its boundaries.
- The district register for CBZ names no provision that establishes it
A drafting decision for Scarborough.
found by comparison
No provision establishes Resource Protection
Resource Protection is drawn on the zoning map and regulated elsewhere in the bylaw, and no provision establishes it or fixes its boundaries.
- The district register for RP names no provision that establishes it
A drafting decision for Scarborough.
found by comparison
The amendment record 1
Where Scarborough's own record of what it adopted disagrees with the text it adopted, or with itself. These are questions for the Clerk's files rather than for the Town Council.
Two amendments to this chapter had their second reading after this edition, on November 4, 2026
The Town's edition is amended as of October 21, 2026. The Town Council's agenda for November 4, 2026 carried the second reading of two orders amending Chapter 405, after public hearings on October 21, 2026. As of November 14, 2026 the Town has not published the minutes of that meeting (the November 18 agenda says they are not available) or a newer edition, so whether either was adopted, and in what words, is not known here. If they were, the text published here lacks them.
- Order No. 26-073: amendments to Section VI (definitions of Forestry Operations Notification, Timber Harvesting and Timber Harvesting Activities) and to the streetscape buffer minimums of Sections XVII.A, XVIII.A, XVIII.B, XVIII.C, XVIII.D, XVIII.E, XIX, XIX.A, XX, XX.A and XX.B (20 feet on all other streets); Town Council agenda, November 4, 2026, item 12.1
- Order No. 26-081: amendments to Section VI adding a definition of Data Center (prohibited in all zoning districts) and excluding data centers from High Technology Facility and Research, Development, and Light Industrial; Town Council agenda, November 4, 2026, item 12.3
- Town Council minutes, October 21, 2026: public hearings on Orders 26-073 and 26-081, second readings scheduled for November 4, 2026
Read the November 4, 2026 minutes when the Town posts them and, if either order was adopted, convert the Town's next edition or the adopted text.
read from the Town's materials
Between the bylaw and the map 3
The ordinance and the zoning map are one instrument, and these are the places where they do not agree.
1 district code(s) the text establishes are not on the map layer
[Automated statute and consistency scan, low confidence.] The bylaw names these districts with a code in parentheses and the map layer we hold has no polygon carrying that code. Overlay districts commonly sit on a separate layer; a base district missing from the map is a gap.
- Text names (TTOD); map has no TTOD
Check whether each is an overlay on another layer or a base district the map should carry.
read from the Town's materials
1 map district code(s) never appear in the bylaw text
[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The zoning map layer carries these district codes, and the converted bylaw text never writes them. Either the map uses abbreviations the bylaw does not (the bylaw may name the district in words), the layer is not the map of record, or the text is stale.
- Map code RP: no match in text
Match each code to the district the bylaw establishes by name, in districts.yaml, or replace the layer.
read from the Town's materials
The Town's zoning layer is dated 2023 and still draws a deleted overlay
The Town's GIS zoning layer (gisserver.scarborough.me.us, CorsonWebGIS/Zoning, layer 8) records no approval date later than June 21, 2023, so a rezoning adopted since may not be drawn. Its overlay service still carries an "Economic Development Overlay", the Exit 42 Economic Development Overlay District that Section VII.B says was deleted on 06/20/2012; it is not published here. Section II.C says the Official Zoning Map is kept as a PDF attested by the Town Clerk; that PDF, not the GIS layer, is the map of record.
- Zoning layer: latest APPVDATE 2023-06-21
- Section VII.B: "[Deleted 06/20/1]"; ZoningOverlayDistricts layer 8 "Economic_Development_Overlay"
Compare the layer with the Town Clerk's current Official Zoning Map before relying on a boundary.
read from the Town's materials
Worth taking up at the next amendment 1
Nothing here contradicts anything, and nothing here exceeds the statute. These are places where what is written makes the ordinance harder to administer, to cite or to read than it needs to be. Each is still a change only Scarborough can make.
1 term(s) are defined more than once
[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] A term with two definitions in one bylaw means one reading or the other, and the site resolves a use of the term to the nearest definition in scope. Where the two are the same words in two places that is only untidy; where they differ it is a drafting question.
- “contractor’s office shop and storage yard” defined in §§ VI, VI
Compare the definitions; if they differ, say which governs where.
read from the Town's materials