Zoning audit
Town of Harpswell
9 things worth a decision in
the Basic Land Use Ordinance: places where it does not agree with something else in it, with
the contents, with the zoning map or with the Town's own record of what it has amended, and places where it would be easier to administer written another
way. Each names the evidence, and says whose decision it is.
None of them are corrected in the published text. The
ordinance on this site reads exactly as Harpswell prints it, and
changing any of this is an amendment rather than a correction.
Against the text current through March 14, 2026
Needs a drafting decision 4
The ordinance contradicts itself or is incomplete here. Only Harpswell can settle these, and only by amendment — correcting them here would state as law something Harpswell has never adopted.
§ 10.4.4.2Two citations that appear to point at the wrong provision
§ 10.4.4.2 speaks of "the frontage and lot size requirements of subparagraph 10.4.3."; the requirements it describes (one hundred feet of frontage and twenty thousand square feet) are those of 10.4.4.1. Table 1's footnote 20, "Only as provided in Section 13.1.2. of the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance", stands on the Interior cell of 15.8 Community Shoreland Access; the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance's 13.1.2 is the home occupation in Resource Protection, and its 13.1.3 Harpswell shoreland access exception. Both are published as printed.
- § 10.4.4.2: "Any lots that do not meet the frontage and lot size requirements of subparagraph 10.4.3. Are reconfigured or combined so that each new lot contains at least one hundred (100) feet of road frontage and twenty thousand (20,000) square feet of lot area."
Decide whether "10.4.3" should read "10.4.4.1", and where footnote 20 belongs.
read from the Town's materials
10 cited section number(s) do not exist in the text (12 citations)
[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The bylaw cites sections by number that the converted text does not contain. Some are references to other bylaws or to a superseded numbering; some will be sections the PDF reader failed to recognise. Either way a reader who follows the citation finds nothing.
- § 15.20 cited 3 time(s); e.g. § 11 11.16.: “…me Occupations. All home occupations are subject to the provisions of Section 15.20 of the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance setting forth performance standards…”
- § 15.4 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § 11 11.7.: “…grounds shall be subject to the same provisions as those set forth in Section 15.4 of the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance, as may be amended from time to tim…”
- § 15.5 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § 11 11.8.: “…al uses shall be subject to the same provisions as those set forth in Section 15.5 of the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance, as may be amended from time to tim…”
- § 15.13 cited 1 time(s); e.g. § 11 11.9.: “…culture shall be subject to the same provisions as those set forth in Section 15.13 of the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance, as may be amended from time to tim…”
For each number, decide whether it is a stale citation to amend or a section the conversion missed to re-read.
read from the Town's materials
No provision establishes Eagle Island Historic District
Eagle Island Historic District is drawn on the zoning map and regulated elsewhere in the bylaw, and no provision establishes it or fixes its boundaries.
- The district register for EIHD names no provision that establishes it
A drafting decision for Harpswell.
found by comparison
No provision establishes Tower District
Tower District is drawn on the zoning map and regulated elsewhere in the bylaw, and no provision establishes it or fixes its boundaries.
- The district register for TD names no provision that establishes it
A drafting decision for Harpswell.
found by comparison
The amendment record 1
Where Harpswell's own record of what it adopted disagrees with the text it adopted, or with itself. These are questions for the Clerk's files rather than for Town Meeting.
Amendments in preparation in 2026 have not gone to a town meeting
The Select Board's minutes of August 27, 2026 report the Town Planner's update on "draft ordinance amendments concerning docks and subdivisions": the Planning Board reviewed them, held a public hearing, and concluded that more review was needed. Its minutes of October 8, 2026 record the Housing Committee "developing potential ordinance amendments and housing-related policy initiatives". No town meeting has acted on either (the June 9, 2026 referendum's one question was the Animal Control Ordinance; the November 3, 2026 ballot was the State's). Nothing of them is published here.
- Select Board minutes, August 27, 2026, item 7: "Ordinance Amendment Update Re: Docks in Subdivisions"
None until a town meeting acts.
read from the Town's materials
Between the bylaw and the map 3
The ordinance and the zoning map are one instrument, and these are the places where they do not agree.
§ 13The map draws the Mitchell Field Marine Business District as it stood before March 11, 2023
The Annual Town Meeting of March 11, 2023 (Article 5; the results: "Articles 3 - 5 Ordinance & Map amendments – passed") voted "to amend the boundaries of the Mitchell Field Marine Business District as shown on the plan “Proposed Amendment to the Harpswell Shoreland Zoning Map March 2023” prepared by Harty and Harty and dated January 9, 2023", a copy of which the warrant attaches (a progress plot): a rectangle of 273.9 by 355.0 feet rezoned from the Interior District to the Mitchell Field Marine Business District, an area of the district rezoned to the Interior District, and a strip along Mitchell Field Drive rezoned to the Shoreland Residential District. The Town's Shoreland Zoning layer, from which the map here is drawn, still draws the district's earlier boundary (its polygon is identical to the one in the Town's "FinalProposedZoningDec20112" layer), the Official Shoreland Zoning Map the Town posts is the 2013 adoption, and the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance's cover lists no March 2023 amendment. The change is not drawn here. Whether the Commissioner of Environmental Protection approved it (Shoreland Zoning Ordinance § 11.1.3) was not checked.
- Warrant of March 11, 2023, Article 5: "To see if the Town will vote to amend the boundaries of the Mitchell Field Marine Business District as shown on the plan “Proposed Amendment to the Harpswell Shoreland Zoning Map March 2023” prepared by Harty and Harty and dated January 9, 2023, a copy of which is attached."
Ask the Town for the map as amended, or a georeferenced copy of the plan, and draw the change.
read from the Town's materials
7 map district code(s) never appear in the bylaw text
[Automated statute and consistency scan, medium confidence.] The zoning map layer carries these district codes, and the converted bylaw text never writes them. Either the map uses abbreviations the bylaw does not (the bylaw may name the district in words), the layer is not the map of record, or the text is stale.
- Map code INT: no match in text
- Map code SR: no match in text
- Map code SB: no match in text
- Map code CFI: no match in text
Match each code to the district the bylaw establishes by name, in districts.yaml, or replace the layer.
read from the Town's materials
The Tower District is on the Official Shoreland Zoning Map and in no ordinance the Town posts
The Official Shoreland Zoning Map adopted March 9, 2013 lists a "Tower District" in its legend, and the Town's layer draws it (35.6 ha on Harpswell Neck). Neither this ordinance, the Shoreland Zoning Ordinance (§ 11.1 lists seven districts, not this one), nor the Wireless Telecommunications Facilities Ordinance establishes a Tower District; the last names "the parcel on which the Harpswell television transmitting tower is located" among its priority locations (§ 8.2.1.1). The map publishes it as an overlay of that name over the Interior.
- Official Shoreland Zoning Map, legend: "Tower District"
Ask the Town what the Tower District is and whether the map should still show it.
read from the Town's materials
Worth taking up at the next amendment 1
Nothing here contradicts anything, and nothing here exceeds the statute. These are places where what is written makes the ordinance harder to administer, to cite or to read than it needs to be. Each is still a change only Harpswell can make.
§ 13Section 13 numbers two divisions 13.3
Table 1 is titled "13.3. TABLE 1. LAND USES AND ACTIVITIES" and the division after it "13.3. Permit and Approval Application"; the contents list both as 13.3, and 13.4 to 13.6 follow. Both are published as printed. Elsewhere: § 11.12 letters its standards (a) to (d), then (f) to (h), with no (e); Table 1's repeated head prints "CF2" for "CFII".
- Table 1, title row: "13.3. TABLE 1. LAND USES AND ACTIVITIES"; next division: "13.3. Permit and Approval Application"
Renumber at the next housekeeping amendment.
read from the Town's materials